| On Prediction Markets There are lots of arguments about 'prediction markets.' Some of the most important are about the opportunities they create for corruption and the general social ills tied to what is essentially gambling. But the one that perpetually puts a bee in my bonnet is the frequently-advanced idea that prediction markets are superior to polls as predictors of election outcomes. I was reminded of this by the upset Lula win in yesterday's Brazilian presidential election. Kalshi had candidate Fla'vio Bolsonaro with 76% odds of winning until the first returns came in and he lost. Obviously, polls and every other kind of prognostication have misses too. Those don't discredit the whole enterprise. The problem with the argument about prediction markets and polls is both empirical and logical. Empirically they do not appear to be better. But the comparison is difficult if not impossible since polls don't generate odds or probabilities. They approximate current levels of support. It's easy to look fast and think those two things are the same. But they're not. Logically, prediction markets cannot be 'better' than polls since they are mostly derivative of polls; they are overwhelmingly reliant on polls. |